Nearly nine in ten mortgage brokers say lenders have been too slow to adapt to borrowers whose financial circumstances fall outside conventional criteria. The finding puts the treatment of business owners, contractors and people with several income sources at the centre of the mortgage-access debate.
Nottingham Building Society’s The Doorstep Divide research, covered by Mortgage Solutions on 16 November, found that 88% of brokers considered lenders too slow to respond. Some 90% wanted greater priority given to products serving a wider range of financial circumstances.
Separate consumer findings show that 58% of UK adults believe people with non-traditional income are judged more harshly than salaried applicants. These are respondents’ views, rather than a measure of rejection rates or evidence that every affected household could afford the mortgage it wanted.
88% of brokers say lenders have been too slow to adapt; 90% want products for a broader range of circumstances. The issue is how borrowing is assessed when earnings and financial histories do not fit conventional criteria.
Recent coverage, with research conducted earlier in the year
The November reporting follows coverage of the same headline findings by Financial Reporter on 26 October. This is follow-up scrutiny of an established problem, rather than a newly conducted November poll.
The report’s methodology identifies a Censuswide survey of 500 UK mortgage intermediaries conducted from 2 to 9 March 2026. Its main consumer findings come from 2,081 UK adults surveyed from 4 to 11 September, with some separately identified findings from a March consumer survey.
That timing matters. The results describe experiences and perceptions gathered earlier this year. They cannot establish how much access has improved or deteriorated since then, or measure the effect of subsequent lender changes.
Following Willow’s reporting on company director borrowing
Willow previously examined the expansion of profit-based assessment for eligible company directors. This research puts that practical issue in a wider context: the income a lender recognises can be as consequential as the maximum multiple it advertises.
Complex finances can exist alongside a strong credit record
The borrowers under discussion include people whose earnings are profitable, established and properly documented. A director may receive salary and dividends while leaving profits in the company. A consultant may work under successive contracts. A professional may combine employment with freelance work.
Those circumstances create different questions from missed payments or unresolved debt. The lender needs to understand how earnings arise, whether they are likely to continue and what evidence supports them. An applicant can have an excellent repayment record while still needing more detailed income assessment.
The report also considers people affected by divorce, illness, career breaks or limited credit histories. Their needs should not be treated as identical. A change in household commitments, a gap in earnings and a historic credit problem each require different evidence and may lead to different lending options.
A director’s personal income may not capture the business’s earnings
For company directors, the distinction between money earned by the business and money paid to its owner is particularly relevant. Personal salary and dividends describe the amounts extracted. Company accounts provide information about profits, liabilities and the resources required to keep trading.
Published lender policies demonstrate that the assessment methods differ. NatWest’s self-employed criteria assess relevant company directors through salary and dividends and exclude retained profit. Accord’s criteria allow an alternative using salary and a share of net profit after corporation tax for qualifying shareholders, subject to its ownership, evidence and sustainability requirements.
For a profitable owner-managed business, that difference can change the income considered before any borrowing multiple is applied. It also explains why a borrowing estimate based solely on personal drawings may not settle the question across all suitable lenders.
There are limits to that argument. Accumulated reserves are not the same as recurring annual profit, and a company bank balance is not automatically disposable personal cash. Dividends distributed from a profit figure must not be added again to that same profit. The household still needs a sustainable way to meet its repayments while preserving the business’s commitments.
Evidence requirements can become a barrier before pricing is discussed
Financial Reporter’s coverage identifies initial affordability assessment and evidence requirements as common points where viable complex-income cases stall, each cited by 19% of brokers. That finding concerns where brokers see difficulties; it does not mean 19% of all applications fail at either stage.
The practical difficulty is often assembling a consistent explanation from several documents. Accounts may cover a different period from a personal tax return. A dividend may be paid annually while salary arrives monthly. A temporary reduction in profit may need to be explained alongside subsequent trading.
Providing more paperwork alone does not resolve those differences. The figures need to reconcile, the relevant income policy needs to be understood and material changes need to be explained. An accountant can help establish what the records show; the lender must still decide what it can accept.
Willow’s guide to self-employed mortgage assessment examines how the required evidence varies between sole traders, company directors and contractors. The useful starting point is the applicant’s actual income structure, rather than a generic document list.
A low estimate can cause borrowers to stop looking too soon
A borrower who receives an unexpectedly low figure may assume it represents the maximum available anywhere. The published differences between lender policies show why that conclusion can be premature. Another suitable lender may calculate accepted income differently, although that does not guarantee a larger loan.
Equally, a higher income figure cannot resolve every constraint. MoneyHelper’s affordability guidance explains that lenders consider spending and employment circumstances alongside earnings. Deposit size, existing commitments and the property can still restrict the result.
For homeowners who have become self-employed since their last application, the same questions can arise at remortgage. A previous approval based on employment income does not establish how a new lender will assess the current business. Understanding that position before the existing deal ends gives more time to prepare the evidence and compare suitable options.
The useful response is a more precise assessment of the case
The survey adds weight to calls for clearer criteria and more consistent evidence requirements. It does not establish that lending standards should be relaxed, or that every borrower with complex finances needs a specialist-priced product.
For an applicant facing a shortfall, the first task is to identify its cause. Was income excluded, averaged or capped? Was the difficulty the deposit, the monthly budget, the credit history or the property? Those answers determine whether a different lender’s approach could help.
For accountants and other professional advisers, the research reinforces the value of an early financing discussion before a client changes remuneration or commits to a purchase. An informed review can establish what suitable lenders may recognise, without assuming that taxable drawings alone define the available borrowing.
Does your mortgage assessment reflect how you earn?
If salary, dividends, company profits, contract work or several income sources have produced an unexpectedly low borrowing figure, Willow can review the calculation, supporting evidence and suitable residential lending options alongside your deposit and commitments.
Explore Complex-Income Mortgage OptionsFrequently asked questions
Does the 88% figure mean most complex-income mortgage applications are rejected?
No. It is the proportion of surveyed brokers who said lenders were too slow to adapt to borrowers’ non-standard circumstances. It is an opinion measure, not an application rejection rate or proof that a particular borrower should be approved.
Does non-standard income mean I have adverse credit?
No. Variable earnings, self-employment, dividends or several income sources can require a different assessment even where credit conduct is strong. Income structure and credit history are separate parts of the application, although some borrowers face issues in both areas.
Can company profits count if I have not taken them as dividends?
Potentially. Some lenders can consider salary alongside an eligible share of company profit, while others rely on salary and dividends. Ownership, profit trends, tax, business commitments and sustainability matter. Accumulated reserves are not automatically annual income, and the same profit must not be counted twice.
What evidence can help explain complex income?
The appropriate documents depend on how you earn and the lender’s requirements. They may include accounts, tax calculations, tax year overviews, bank statements, payslips, contracts and an accountant’s explanation of material changes. Documents should reconcile with the income being presented.
Should I apply elsewhere after an unsuccessful mortgage application?
First establish why the application was unsuccessful. A different income policy may help if the problem was how earnings were assessed. It will not necessarily resolve unaffordable repayments, an insufficient deposit or an unsuitable property. A review should identify realistic options before another application.

